MathPuzzle

Free puzzles / Question / Money Puzzles

Queer Relationships.

"Speaking of relationships," said the Parson at a certain dinner-party, "our legislators are getting the marriage law into a frightful tangle, Here, for example, is a puzzling case that has come under my notice. Two brothers married two sisters. One man died and the other man's wife also died. Then the survivors married." "The man married his deceased wife's sister under the recent Act?" put in the Lawyer. "Exactly. And therefore, under the civil law, he is legally married and his child is legitimate. But, you see, the man is the woman's deceased husband's brother, and therefore, also under the civil law, she is not married to him and her child is illegitimate." "He is married to her and she is not married to him!" said the Doctor. "Quite so. And the child is the legitimate son of his father, but the illegitimate son of his mother." "Undoubtedly 'the law is a hass,'" the Artist exclaimed, "if I may be permitted to say so," he added, with a bow to the Lawyer. "Certainly," was the reply. "We lawyers try our best to break in the beast to the service of man. Our legislators are responsible for the breed." "And this reminds me," went on the Parson, "of a man in my parish who married the sister of his widow. This man--" "Stop a moment, sir," said the Professor. "Married the sister of his widow? Do you marry dead men in your parish?" "No; but I will explain that later. Well, this man has a sister of his own. Their names are Stephen Brown and Jane Brown. Last week a young fellow turned up whom Stephen introduced to me as his nephew. Naturally, I spoke of Jane as his aunt, but, to my astonishment, the youth corrected me, assuring me that, though he was the nephew of Stephen, he was not the nephew of Jane, the sister of Stephen. This perplexed me a good deal, but it is quite correct." The Lawyer was the first to get at the heart of the mystery. What was his solution?

Answer

The age of Mary to that of Ann must be as 5 to 3. And as the sum of their ages was 44, Mary was 271/2 and Ann 161/2. One is exactly 11 years older than the other. I will now insert in brackets in the original statement the various ages specified: "Mary is (271/2) twice as old as Ann was (133/4) when Mary was half as old (243/4) as Ann will be (491/2) when Ann is three times as old (491/2) as Mary was (161/2) when Mary was (161/2) three times as old as Ann (51/2)." Now, check this backwards. When Mary was three times as old as Ann, Mary was 161/2 and Ann 51/2 (11 years younger). Then we get 491/2 for the age Ann will be when she is three times as old as Mary was then. When Mary was half this she was 243/4. And at that time Ann must have been 133/4 (11 years younger). Therefore Mary is now twice as old--271/2, and Ann 11 years younger--161/2.